Bakers Square Menu
Bakers Square menu gallery
Choose your favorite dish
Whole Pies & Cakes
A creamy vanilla layer garnished with fresh bananas covered in a sweet strawberry glaze topped with fresh strawberries, whipped cream and a banana chip.
Layers of our dark chocolate French Silk and chunky peanut butter cup silk inside our own, unique peanut-graham cracker crust. Topped with real whipped cream, chocolate peanut butter cups and roasted peanuts, then drizzled with chocolate ganache and caramel.
Our best seller! Velvety smooth chocolate silk covered with real whipped cream and milk chocolate curls, inside our award-winning pastry crust.
Toasted Texas pecans and a luxurious caramel filling are baked inside our golden, flaky pie crust. One of our most award winning pies!
An award-winning and traditional treat made with real pumpkin custard spiced to perfection with Saigon cinnamon, ginger and nutmeg, baked inside our award-winning pastry crust.
Real pumpkin custard spiced to perfection with Saigon cinnamon, ginger and nutmeg, baked inside our award-winning pastry crust and topped with real whipped cream.
A rich and decadent pie featuring a layer of our classic French Silk, a creamy supreme filling, and a layer of caramel and Texas pecans. Topped with real whipped cream and drizzled with chocolate sauce, caramel and pecans.
Sweet, crisp Michigan Northern Spy apples seasoned to perfection with Saigon cinnamon and covered in our flaky, award-winning pastry crust.
Sweet, crisp Michigan Northern Spy apples seasoned to perfection with Saigon cinnamon and covered in our flaky, award-winning pastry crust, with no added sugar. Made with NutraSweet®.
Juicy, tart Michigan red cherries inside our award-winning pastry crust
We created the perfect combination of sweet and tart with strawberries and rhubarb baked together inside our light, flaky pastry crust.
Tart raspberries, plump, wild Maine blueberries, and juicy Northeastern blackberries blend together to create a pie that's bursting with flavor.
Sweet, sun-ripened California peaches inside our golden, flaky pastry crust. This pie is a multiple time blue ribbon winner!
This iconic Florida favorite features a sweet, creamy filling made with tart key limes and served on a graham cracker crust.
Whipped and baked egg whites are toasted to golden brown to make the light, fluffy meringue that sits on top of an irresistible, tangy lemon filling inside our flaky pastry crust.
Layers of tangy lemon filling and cool, creamy supreme filling inside our flaky, golden pie crust, then topped with real whipped cream.
A rich and creamy New York-style cheesecake baked inside a honey-graham crust.
Four-layer cake with shredded carrots, pineapple, sweetened coconut and pecan pieces, covered in cream cheese frosting.
A light, fluffy meringue dusted with toasted coconut flakes that sits atop a delectable, creamy coconut filling inside our flaky pastry crust.
A delicious vanilla cream filling layered with fresh, ripe banana slices inside our award-winning pastry crust. Topped with real whipped cream and toasted almonds.
12 oz of whipped cream to dollop onto your favorite pie!
Bakers Square offers a dessert-focused menu that highlights its signature selection of classic American pies and cakes, designed for sharing or special occasions. The standout offerings in the Whole Pies & Cakes category include Whole Strawberry Banana Pie, Whole Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup Pie, Whole French Silk Pie, Whole Southern Pecan Pie, and Whole Harvest Pumpkin Pie. Each option reflects a traditional bakery-style approach, combining rich fillings with familiar flavors that appeal to both seasonal cravings and year-round dessert lovers. The fruit-forward Whole Strawberry Banana Pie brings a lighter, refreshing sweetness, while indulgent choices like Whole Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup Pie and Whole French Silk Pie emphasize creamy, decadent textures. Nutty and comforting profiles are represented by Whole Southern Pecan Pie, and the warmly spiced Whole Harvest Pumpkin Pie captures a classic seasonal favorite. Overall, the menu is clearly centered on well-known pie varieties, making Bakers Square a destination for those seeking whole desserts meant for gatherings, celebrations, or simply taking home a traditional slice of American comfort baking.